Download the 360 Evaluation Template
Excel template with questions and evaluator network, ready to use.
Millions of 360 Degree Evaluations implemented in recent years have given us a very broad view of all the advantages they offer and the best practices for building and applying them.
With this guide, our goal is to help every Human Resources department create, apply, and analyze their own 360-degree evaluation to increase the development and performance of all their employees.
What You Need to Know
- 1. What is a 360-Degree Evaluation?
- It's an evaluation process in which an employee receives feedback from multiple perspectives: their manager, peers, direct reports, and internal clients.
- 2. What does it evaluate?
- It evaluates soft skills such as leadership, emotional intelligence, personal values, teamwork, communication, creativity, and organization, among others.
- 3. What is a 360-Degree Evaluation for?
- It helps identify strengths and areas for improvement, supports employees in defining their development agendas, and promotes professional growth.
- 4. Who takes part in the evaluation?
- They're typically used to evaluate people in leadership roles, and in organizations further along in the process, they can be extended to all employees.
- 5. Is the feedback confidential?
- Initially, evaluations tend to be anonymous to encourage employee participation and openness, though this can change over time as the organization matures.
What Is a 360-Degree Evaluation?
A 360-Degree Evaluation is the set of feedback on professional and personal competencies that an employee receives from their coworkers, which helps identify their main strengths and areas for improvement.
It's called 360° because it includes the self-evaluation of the employee being assessed, plus the evaluations from their coworkers, including their Direct Manager, Peers, Direct Reports, and Clients.
Looking at the diagram above, we can see that a 360° evaluation is very different from a performance evaluation; more coworkers take part beyond just the Direct Manager. This is what makes 360° evaluations such an enriching experience.
These evaluations are also known as 360 Competency Evaluations, 360 Performance Evaluations, or 360 Surveys.
What Does It Evaluate?
Unlike annual performance evaluations, which score employees on meeting objectives and measurable results, a 360-degree evaluation focuses on the professional and personal competencies that are fundamental to those responsibilities.
These qualities are known as Competencies, and some of the main ones are:
- Leadership. Delegation, Accountability, Motivation, Decision-Making, Risk-Taking, Approachability.
- Emotional Intelligence. Empathy, Stability, Self-Confidence.
- Personal Values. Respect, Ethics, Physical Presentation.
- Teamwork. Participation, Feedback, Accepting Differences, Negotiation.
- Communication. Oral Presentation, Understanding Ideas, Listening Skills.
- Creativity. Problem-Solving, Innovation.
- Organization. Note-Taking, Meeting Responsibilities.
- Organizational Values. Alignment with Vision and Mission, Company Loyalty.
What Is a Competency?
A competency is the capacity or ability a person has in a certain personal or professional area to perform in their role.
What Is a Behavior?
Behaviors are the way we can evaluate or measure a competency. In other words, they are the observable actions that our coworkers rely on to judge our mastery of certain competencies. The point of evaluating behaviors is that it's much easier to evaluate a behavior than a competency.
For example, if you're asked to rate someone's "Leadership" on a scale of 1 to 5, that can be hard to do. But if instead you evaluate "Your coworker keeps their team members motivated and focused on the goals that matter most to the organization," it becomes much easier.
Run 360-Degree Evaluations
Implement comprehensive 360-degree evaluations across your organization.
Can It Be Used to Evaluate Performance?
Absolutely! But only up to a point. A 360 evaluation is not designed to assess whether an employee met their objectives and results. It isn't appropriate for direct reports, clients, or peers to evaluate our results — that's the direct manager's job.
And speaking of the direct manager — which would amount to a 180° evaluation — it's worth noting that relying solely on a subjective performance rating can make it hard to compare across departments, since each manager's personal style will directly affect their team's results.
That said, 360° evaluations do work well for assessing performance when it comes to technical and professional competencies.
The competencies covered in the previous section are aimed specifically at personal skills, but other, more performance-relevant competencies could also be included:
- Technical Knowledge. Mastery of platforms, accounting knowledge, financial knowledge, among others.
- Product or Service Knowledge. Related to the employee's understanding of the product or service the company offers.
- Customer Support. For employees who deal directly with external clients.
- Sales Skills. For employees who deal directly with prospects.
In other words, a 360-degree evaluation can be a key driver for increasing performance and productivity across all employees. That's why it's the perfect complement to a performance evaluation, and particularly useful for measuring an employee's potential.
Step 1: Define the Objective
We can't start implementing a 360° evaluation without a clear objective in mind. Answering these questions will help us carry out the following steps correctly, and ensure every participant has a positive experience.
- Will the evaluation be used only for feedback purposes?
- Will it be used to map employee potential?
- Will it be used to determine raises or bonuses?
- Will it be used as the sole method for evaluating performance?
- Will it be used to build a training needs analysis?
- What other processes will benefit from implementing this evaluation?
There isn't necessarily a right or wrong answer to these questions — while a 360 evaluation is normally used for feedback and development purposes, it can be a valuable exercise for other needs as well.
Once you've answered these questions, it's best to have at least one or two more people from your team help you write the objective of the evaluation and how it connects to the business objective.
Step 2: Select the Employees to Be Evaluated
Because a 360-degree evaluation assesses professional and personal competencies, it's just as suitable for administrative roles as for operational ones. In practice, however, it's difficult to roll it out across the entire organization, so you need to decide how far down the org chart to go, or whether to roll it out in phases.
The best approach is to include all administrative or leadership staff in a first phase, and then move on to the rest of the positions. When selecting leadership roles, an easy way to make this distinction is to filter for people who have direct reports.
If you choose to include only certain roles, make sure to include everyone at that same level, to avoid feelings of exclusion among those left out.
Who Shouldn't Be Included?
Giving or receiving feedback isn't easy, and it becomes even harder for a new hire. Employees being evaluated should have at least 3 to 6 months with the organization. This gives their coworkers enough context to evaluate them properly.
Step 3: Select a Competency Model
This is probably the most important step in a 360° evaluation, and the one that can most affect the results you obtain.
Using a well-designed, proven model will help guarantee the evaluation's success. On the other hand, even small changes to the questions can completely change the results.
Select Competency Areas
One characteristic of 360-degree evaluations is that they assess concepts applicable to the vast majority of organizations.
A good starting point is to review the competency areas mentioned earlier in the "What Does It Evaluate?" section and decide which are most relevant to your organization.
A 360 evaluation typically includes around 8 to 12 competency areas.
When naming your competencies, remember that participants aren't subject-matter experts — use familiar, easy-to-understand terms. For example, call it Delegation, not "Efficiently Distributes Tasks" — that will only create confusion.
Define Behaviors
Each competency should have behaviors to evaluate. In simple terms, behaviors are the questions that help us measure how well the person being evaluated demonstrates that competency. They generally take the form of multiple-choice questions. We recommend questions that are neither too general nor too convoluted — opt for concrete, specific questions.
A few additional recommendations for writing the questions:
- Try to keep the questions roughly the same length — statistically, this helps produce more accurate answers.
- Ask more than one question about the same topic to get better results. We recommend 2 to 3 behaviors per competency.
- Include one or two measurable questions to verify the authenticity of the results.
Include Open-Ended Questions or a Comments Section
Open-ended questions or comments can provide an excellent source of information for the person being evaluated that simply isn't possible to get from multiple-choice questions alone.
Some recommended questions are: "List your coworker's main strengths" or "List your coworker's main areas for improvement."
Length of the Evaluation
The ideal number of questions falls in a range of 40 to 50 total, with no more than 2 open-ended questions. This helps ensure you gather detailed enough information without wearing out your evaluators.
Step 4: Rating Scale
For all multiple-choice questions, you need to define a rating scale to use. Any change to it can drastically alter the results obtained, so it's best to use proven methods.
There are two main schools of thought on how many options the scale should have. Some recommend an even number, others an odd number.
The first approach avoids a middle ground and pushes respondents toward a negative or positive choice. The second adds a neutral option.
In our experience, choosing between an even or odd number of options doesn't significantly change the results. We've seen a bigger impact from two other factors:
Number of Negative / Positive Options
People tend to rate positively in a 360° Evaluation — it's human nature when giving feedback — which is why we frequently end up with results so positive they can seem unrealistic.
One approach we've found helps distinguish the good from the truly great is widening the scale on its positive side. For example, using a 6-option scale where the first two options are negative, the third is neutral, and the last three are positive.
Scale Wording
The next factor that can significantly impact a scale is its wording. Depending on what's being evaluated, it's important that the scale makes sense and is aligned with the results you want to achieve.
The most commonly used scales are:
- Never, Rarely, Sometimes, Usually, Always.
- Strongly Disagree, Disagree, Neither Agree nor Disagree, Agree, Strongly Agree.
- Very Poor, Poor, Fair, Good, Very Good, Excellent.
- Below Requirements, Partially Meets Expectations, Meets Expectations, Masters the Competency, Expert.
Step 5: Define the Evaluator Network
Having selected which job levels will receive feedback and the competency model to evaluate, the next step in building our 360° evaluation is to define the Evaluator Network.
In Step 3 we mentioned that the competency model is the most important step — well, the evaluator network tends to be the most complicated one. No matter how we choose it, some employee will likely voice their disagreement with the process.
Components of the Evaluator Network
Building the evaluator network means selecting who will evaluate each of the participants. It breaks down as follows:
- a. Self-Evaluation.
- The self-evaluation itself is very important as a benchmark for comparison and for identifying each evaluated person's blind spots, while also giving them a chance for self-reflection.
- b. Direct manager.
- Naturally, one of the most important pieces of feedback comes from the direct manager. It offers a more concrete perspective from the person currently holding the role the evaluated employee likely aspires to.
- c. Peers.
- Although it might seem less important than the direct manager's feedback, peer feedback is actually a central part of a 360-degree evaluation. We rarely receive feedback from peers, and it's probably where the most valuable contributions come from.
- d. Direct reports.
- Like peers, direct reports are also central to a 360 evaluation. Even though feedback sessions between managers and employees may already happen, they're rarely done confidentially.
- e. Internal clients.
- This won't apply in every case, but for certain key roles within the organization, it can be important to include feedback from internal clients.
- f. Total evaluators per employee.
- To ensure results are accurate and provide meaningful feedback for the person being evaluated, it's best to have at least 7 to 10 evaluators.
Step 6: Define Confidentiality
Confidentiality is one of the most sensitive topics in a 360-degree evaluation. Should feedback be anonymous? Completely open? Somewhere in between?
At first, it's best for evaluations to be anonymous, with only the averages shared with each employee. As the organization matures, feedback processes can become more open.
What you can do from the start is break down results by relationship type.
The insight you gain from knowing how each relationship within your team rated you is extremely valuable when building action plans to improve your competencies.
Step 7: Run an Awareness Campaign
It's not a good idea to notify participants just a day before the 360-degree evaluation begins — the process should start several weeks in advance, informing everyone about what's coming.
All directors or area managers should be involved from the start, taking part in selecting the competency areas and the evaluator network, and identifying which areas matter most to the company.
Once that's done, all participants should be informed about the 360-degree evaluation, its objectives, and the benefits it offers. It's important they understand the goal isn't to fire the lowest-rated employees or reward the highest-rated ones with a bonus, but rather to help everyone keep improving, both professionally and personally.
I'll say it again: sensitizing employees is extremely important. Doing so will make the process a real success.
Step 8: Roll Out the Evaluation
Once the event is fully set up and ready to launch, you need to give all participants easy, uniform access.
Taking advantage of technology, the most practical approach is to use a technology platform. This not only makes it easier to grant user access, it also simplifies tracking progress, reduces human error, and speeds up data processing and reporting.
In our experience, a 360 evaluation typically takes between 2 to 3 weeks to fully complete.
We recommend sending weekly reminders to participants with pending tasks, plus reminders during the last two days of the evaluation window.
Do You Need 100% Participation?
It would be ideal, but it's neither necessary nor realistic. There will always be someone on vacation, on leave, or simply not committed to the process. Take note of these cases and move forward.
Step 9: Generate Results and Deliver Feedback
Just like the previous step, generating the results shouldn't take much time. Modern systems generate results automatically, allowing HR departments to begin the feedback process quickly and efficiently.
Feedback is the ultimate goal of every 360-degree evaluation, and it's essential to deliver it as effectively as possible to ensure good results. Here are the key points to keep in mind:
- 1. Wait until everyone has finished.
- It's best to give feedback only once the entire organization has finished the evaluations.
- 2. Identify strengths, areas for improvement, and blind spots.
- The report should include their strengths (areas where they scored highest), areas for improvement (areas with the most room to grow), and blind spots (areas where the employee's self-view differs significantly from how their coworkers see them).
- 3. Generate charts.
- The more visual the feedback on 360-degree results, the more easily employees will receive and understand them.
- 4. Give direct feedback to each employee.
- Whether it's an HR team member or the employee's direct manager delivering it, it's best for everyone to receive their results in a one-on-one meeting.
Step 10: Ensure Follow-Up
Implementing a 360-degree evaluation goes far beyond printing the results and handing them to each employee. Proper follow-up is essential, and the more personalized it is, the better the results.
- 1. Build courses and create development plans.
- By identifying which competencies show the greatest room for growth, you can set up training courses and programs.
- 2. Run communication campaigns.
- Just like the campaigns before the evaluations began, it's important to keep communicating throughout the rest of the year, showing the progress made.
Step 11: How Often Should You Apply It?
We've already seen how important it is to follow up with employees and give them feedback. The last thing to consider is bringing this full circle and running the entire process again.
This helps us measure employees' progress and the impact that training programs have had on them.
Our recommendation is that the first time you run 360 evaluations, you wait a full year before running them again. As employees get used to the process and see its benefits, you can move to shorter cycles, ideally every six months.
2026 Trends
In this section, we want to summarize the main changes we see coming in how 360° evaluations are applied.
AI Integration
Artificial intelligence isn't new in 2026 — it's dominated headlines for at least a couple of years now. But 2026 looks to be the year we start finding more practical uses for it in our daily processes.
- a. AI shouldn't write your feedback for you.
- Naturally, many of us turn to AI to generate content, and it might seem logical to use it to help write our feedback. But that would only produce insincere feedback that offers little value to the person receiving it.
- b. It can help analyze our feedback.
- Something very different is writing your feedback first and then using AI to check whether it has what it takes to truly help the recipient — and along the way, catching spelling and grammar mistakes.
Increasing Frequency
It's still very common to hear about annual evaluation processes in organizations, but as employees get more comfortable giving and receiving feedback, more companies are choosing to do it more frequently and with sharper focus.
- a. Shorter evaluations.
- Having multiple check-ins throughout the year lets us make each one more concise, instead of covering 10-15 competencies in a single evaluation.
- b. Continuous feedback.
- If we run shorter, more frequent evaluations, people gradually build a new skill: it becomes easier to give feedback all year round.
Video Summary
If you'd rather watch a quick summary of the article, or share it as a video, click below.
